囧研究：假新闻也有好处？（双语）
Misinformation, fake news, and “alternative facts” are more prominent thanever. The Oxford Dictionary named “post-truth” as the 2016 word of the year.
Science and scientific evidence have been under assault.
假消息、假新闻和“另类事实”比以往任何时候都更为突出。2016年牛津词典将“后真相”列为了年度词汇。科学及科学证据遭受质疑。
Fortunately, science does have a means to protect itself, and it comes from
a branch of psychological research known as inoculation theory. This borrows
from the logic of vaccines: A little bit of something bad helps you resist a
full-blown case.
幸运的是，科学还有一种自保手段，即来自心理学研究分支的接种理论。这一理论借鉴了疫苗的原理：一些不好的东西反而有助于人体抵抗成形的疾病。
TWO WAYS MISINFORMATION DAMAGES
假消息的两种危害
A recent study led by psychology researcher Sander van der Linden found
that misinformation about climate change has a significant impact on public
perceptions about climate change.
近日，心理学研究者桑德·范·得·林登牵头的一项研究发现，关于气候变化的假消息对公众看待气候变化具有重大影响。
I found similar results, with misinformation reducing people’s perception
of the scientific consensus. Moreover, the misinformation affected some more
than others. The more politically conservative a person was, the greater the
influence of the misinformation.
本人也有类似的发现，即假消息削弱了人们对科学共识的认识。而且，某些人受到假消息的影响比其他人更大。例如，一个人政治上越保守，受假消息的影响就越大。
Figure 1. Response to misinformation about climate change.
图1 对于气候变化假消息的反应
Beyond misinforming people, misinformation has a more insidious and
dangerous influence. It doesn’t just misinform. It stops people believing in
facts.
假消息除了误导人，还带来更危险的潜在影响。它不只误导，还阻碍人们相信事实。
SCIENCE’S ANSWER TO SCIENCE DENIAL
“否定科学”的科学解释
Inoculation theory takes the concept of vaccination, where we are exposed
to a weak form of a virus in order to build immunity to the real virus, and
applies it to knowledge.
接种理论采用疫苗接种的概念并将其应用于知识领域。疫苗接种就是让人体感染弱化病毒，以获得抵抗真正病毒的免疫力。
Inoculating text requires two elements. First, it includes an explicit
warning about the danger of being misled by misinformation. Second, you need to
provide counterarguments explaining the flaws in that misinformation.
接种信息需要涵盖两大元素。首先，需要明确警告受到假消息误导的危险。其次，需要提供反驳依据，解释假消息的漏洞。
I found that explaining the misinformation technique completely neutralized
the misinformation’s influence, without even mentioning the misinformation
specifically. Moreover, the misinformation was neutralized across the political
spectrum. Whether you’re conservative or liberal, no one wants to be deceived by
misleading techniques.
本人发现，无需专门提及具体的假消息内容，光是解释假消息漏洞百出的方法便可以抵消其影响。而且，假消息对不同政治倾向的人群的影响都会被抵消。不管保守派还是自由党，没有人愿意被误导人的方法欺骗到。
PUTTING INOCULATION INTO PRACTICE
接种理论引入实践
Inoculation is a powerful and versatile form of science communication that
can be used in a number of ways. My approach has been to mesh together the
findings of inoculation with the cognitive psychology of debunking, developing
the Fact-Myth-Fallacy framework.
接种理论作为一种功能众多且强大的科学解释，用途十分广泛。本人通过把接种理论的成果和揭露真相的认知心理学联系在一起，发展出一套“事实—迷思—谬误”框架。
This strategy involves explaining the facts, followed by introducing a myth
related to those facts. At this point, people are presented with two conflicting
pieces of information. You reconcile the conflict by explaining the technique
that the myth uses to distort the fact.
这一策略包括对事实进行解释，然后引入与这些事实有关的迷思。这时，人们会看到两个相互矛盾的信息。通过揭示迷思扭曲事实所采取的方法便可以化解矛盾。
Table 1. Denial101x lectures adhering to Fact-Myth-Fallacy structure.
表1 遵循“事实—迷思—谬误”框架的“否定事实”入门课
Science has, in a moment of frankness, informed us that throwing more
science at people isn’t the full answer to science denial. Misinformation is a
reality that we can’t afford to ignore–we can’t be in denial about science
denial. Rather, we should see it as an educational opportunity. Addressing
misconceptions in the classroom is one of the most powerful ways to teach
science.
科学明白地告诉我们，向人们灌输更多的科学常识并不能完全解决否定科学的问题。我们无法忽视存在假消息的现实，我们不能否认存在否定科学的事实。相反，我们应该把它看成一个教育契机。课堂上阐释误解是教授科学的最有效方法之一。
It turns out the key to stopping science denial is to expose people to just
a little bit of science denial.
事实证明，阻止否定科学的关键是让人们看到一小部分对科学的否定。
页:
[1]